Alex Hunt: Welcome back to the Texas Family Lawyer Podcast. I'm Alex Hunt, the managing attorney at Hunt Law Firm. And today, I'm very excited to have an in-depth conversation with former judge Cindy Aguirre. She's a former practicing attorney in Fort Bend County. She then took the bench as the associate judge of the 505th District Court, and now she is back in private practice as an amicus attorney and as a certified mediator. She's worked with us on plenty of cases and gotten us resolutions. Judge Aguirre, thank you so much for joining me.
Cindy Aguirre: I'm delighted to be here. Thank you for having me, Alex.
Alex Hunt: And our topic today for this video is for anybody that has either a divorce or child custody case and is interested in learning more about the different individuals that could potentially be helpful in your case. So, an amicus attorney, a parenting facilitator, a parenting coordinator, or if you're maybe going to get a child custody evaluation. All of these individuals could, but won't necessarily, be helpful to your child custody case. So, we're going to talk a little bit about the circumstances where it might be helpful, what their role is, and how it looks in practice. So, tell us a little bit about your background before we jump in.
Cindy Aguirre: Well, I didn't go to law school to do family law. My thought was that I was going to be doing transactional work. But I share that with people because I think those of us that do work in the family law field have to have a certain knack for it. It's sort of like a sixth sense. When I started working in family law, I had a wonderful mentor, and he introduced me to the amicus role. Because I speak Spanish, I'm originally from Venezuela, I think the courts needed help getting an amicus attorney involved in cases in which the parents only spoke Spanish. That's how I got started, and then it just kind of took a life of its own. Over the course of my 23 years of practice, the bulk of it ended up being that work. I also litigated and represented parents, but the more I became involved in the amicus work and in representing children's best interests, it grew to assisting the court in CPS cases for a lot of the same reasons. It just kind of evolved from that. I got to understand the role very well, and then it led up to Judge Perwin asking me to join him on the bench.
Alex Hunt: I didn't know that you did transactional work before. What kind of work did you do?
Cindy Aguirre: I actually never did. That was what I aspired to do. The bulk of my studies were to do international transaction-type work. I thought I was going to be doing oil and gas, paper transactions, or maybe being the liaison between international companies, and I never did that. I ended up just falling into it. I met John Grub. I don't know if you remember him, but he became a great mentor and he specialized in family law. That's my start, and I owe it to him.
Alex Hunt: You mentioned that family law isn't for everybody. When we're looking for new attorneys, folks will apply and they really don't have any background, or their resume doesn't show any interest in family law. That's always kind of a red flag for me, because I feel like if you don't intentionally want to do this work, it's not going to be for you. It is very emotionally taxing, and you need to want to do it. What are some of the things you have done, since you've been doing this for a while, to continue to be able to do this work? Maybe you don't work on Saturdays, or you put down email. What are ways you're able to continue doing this work for so long without burning out?
Cindy Aguirre: That's a good question. I don't think I really grew into being able to create that space for myself until much later in my practice, so much more recently now. After I shifted to working in a judicial capacity, of course, my Saturdays were gone and my after hours were gone. For the litigators, you have to recognize that you can't do everything. You have to recognize that sometimes time has a way of helping things sort themselves out. And I think you do have to set up boundaries. I try to make time for my runs in the mornings. The shift in my practice means I'm mediating throughout the day now, so I'll make some phone calls in the evenings, but once I'm home, I'm home. There's no checking emails and no making phone calls. You have to set up those boundaries, and I think that's very healthy. Litigants don't want a lawyer who's totally burned out and answering emails at all hours of the day.
Alex Hunt: I remember before you took the bench, when I first started practicing in Fort Bend County, you were kind of like the go-to amicus attorney. I think maybe partially for that reason, it seems like Judge Perwin said, "This is who I need as my associate judge," somebody with a really strong background in how to work with kids and families and help decide these child custody cases. But you were an amicus attorney. Can you talk a little bit about what an amicus attorney is and what that role looks like in Texas?
Cindy Aguirre: I think there's a huge misunderstanding out there. For people that don't do this for a living, people tend to think that an amicus attorney is there to do what the child wants, and is hired by a parent or both parents to find out what my kid wants, and that's what we're doing. That's really not at all what the role is about. The role of the amicus attorney is huge, for the court. The client of the amicus attorney, technically, is the court. The role is designed to go out and get an in-person look, to set eyes on what's really going on within a family unit that is in the middle of this conflict, and to help the court decipher what's in a child's best interest.
What does that look like? You have to engage with the parents and find out what's going on in the day-to-day life of the child. Obviously, you speak to the child in the child's environment, in the home of both parents, and kind of hang out with them. It's not interrogatory. It's not like a forensic interview. The tools are to develop a rapport with a child who can then, in confidence, just tell you what they want. Although that's a factor, experience helps you determine whether that's really what the child needs at the time that the conflict is going to be presented to the court. An amicus attorney is representing what the best interest of the child is.
Alex Hunt: There's another role, an attorney ad litem, that's used in general more in child welfare, CPS cases than child custody cases. Can you explain the difference between an amicus attorney and an attorney ad litem?
Cindy Aguirre: I think the most significant difference is the legal aspect of it. The amicus attorney can, on his or her own, act in front of the court, file motions, subpoena witnesses, and make legal argument. The ad litems are there in a lot of the same investigatory role that the amicus attorney has, so they also develop a rapport with the family and the child and find out what needs have to be met. But the ad litem can be a witness. It's more about sharing with the court the continuing needs of this child within this context. The legal aspect of it is not there for the guardian ad litem. I think that's the most significant difference.
Alex Hunt: I've done quite a bit of child welfare work, and depending on what age my client is, sometimes they're early elementary school age, one of my first things is to explain what my role is to them. I'll explain the difference between an attorney ad litem and, in a CPS case, a guardian ad litem, which is similar to the role of an amicus attorney, where they're representing the best interest of the child. I'll say, if you tell me that you want to eat ice cream for dinner every night, as the attorney ad litem, I have an obligation to go to the court and file the brief and say that my client wants to have ice cream every night for dinner. It doesn't mean you're going to get it, but my job is to advocate for what you want. As the guardian ad litem or the amicus attorney, my job is to use my best judgment to determine whether that's in your best interest and then represent that to the court. It's a very simplified way of explaining it. But you don't see a lot of attorneys ad litem in divorce cases and child custody cases. You're more likely to see an amicus attorney. As somebody who has worn the hat of an amicus attorney and also seen good lawyering on the bench, what makes a good amicus attorney in your view, in the world of high conflict situations that require the assistance of an amicus attorney?
Cindy Aguirre: You have to have an amicus attorney that's going to have a voice. The parties are going to spend money paying for a third attorney that's involved in every aspect of the case once that appointment is signed off on. If the amicus attorney is going to be helpful, there has to be time spent interviewing people and talking to the people that matter in this child's life. They have to follow up on what the parents are asking for to see if there's any truth behind their concerns, or the weight of whatever it is that they think is important for their child, so that you can make all of that information available to the court.
But you have to have a stance. Even when I was on the bench, by the time a case gets to the court, the court is aware that the parties have gone through all of the requirements. They've mediated, they've gone to therapy, all of these things have already taken place by the time you get before the bench. For an amicus attorney to get to that end and say, "Judge, everybody is good, they're great, and we can all get along," I think is sometimes problematic, because the court has to make a well-informed decision. We all understand we can't say, "This is what you should do, Court." But you can have a voice to say, "I have looked at all of these things, and what my investigation leads me to believe is that these are the things that are in the child's best interests."
Alex Hunt: I think that's a misconception that a lot of people have. You alluded to this before, that you hire an amicus attorney and they're going to see what the kid wants and then communicate that to the court. Another misconception, I think, is that the amicus attorney is going to be standing before the court and the judge is just going to say, "Amicus attorney, what do you think I should do in this case?" Sometimes there will be opportunities for that to happen. Sometimes an attorney will object to allowing the amicus to kind of testify like that. What are the ways that you demonstrate what is in the child's best interest to the court? How do you get that message across if you can't necessarily come out and say it?
Cindy Aguirre: Presumably by the time that question is asked, if it's ever asked by the court, you've already gone through some of the questioning. Definitely, 100%, it's engaging and having enough information to draw out from whatever witness is testifying what you think makes an impact on the decision that is about to be made. For example, you have a parent who is taking the child to school late. There are 40 tardies. But then you have the teacher on the stand, and you know why those tardies are taking place, because the teacher is aware that "I had that conversation with the parent, and we're doing that because the child needs X, Y, and Z to happen before the day gets started." Whether it's going to the nurse to get medication, or extra time to go over a lesson before class, that's why there's a tardy every time. I'm just giving an example so you know what the right questions are to ask to get the right information in front of the court. It's drawing out those types of things that the litigants themselves, or their attorneys, may not be focusing on.
By the time the judge says, "Well, give me your input," you have the basis to say, "I've looked into these things. I've been in these homes. I've spoken to the child." You have a duty to say, "The 14-year-old wants to live with his father, Judge." Not everybody understands that that's what the child's desires are. But, "Based on the investigations that I've done, or the information that I've reviewed in this case, the parties, the witnesses, and the things that I have done, that's not what is in the child's best interest, for these reasons." And that's okay to do. That's the importance of the role.
Alex Hunt: I think that's another misconception that a lot of people have. You'll have a 12-year-old, and a parent will come to me and say, "My child's turning 12. He's indicated an interest to live with me. Now I want to go to court so we can change custody." But it's not that simple. Just because your child says that they want to live with you, that is typically persuasive on the court, but it's not the be-all and end-all. The judge is still going to be the one making the decision, because this is, in the end, still a child. How did you deal with those situations when you were on the bench, where you had a child that wanted to live with one parent, but you were really torn, and you didn't think that would be in their best interest?
Cindy Aguirre: How did I deal with it? If I interviewed the child, I would try to explain, or try to deflate the situation, by letting them know that nothing they would say as a child is what is going to drive the court to make that decision. The decision rests solely on me, and I tried to lift that burden off of their shoulders. But I also think you have to give some leeway to what is really in a child's best interests. A lot of times at 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, kids don't understand the long-term impact of what a wish like that could be. For example, when you have parents living in different cities and the child says, "No, I really want to move to the other city," and they've never lived there, it's like, well, is that really what's in your best interest? I would meet with high school kids and say, "I understand what you're telling me, but my job is to do what's best for you." You do have to break that down to the child. As an amicus attorney, definitely, because if not, you lose their trust. That's something you have to carry along the way. It's tough.
Alex Hunt: When you were on the bench in the 505th, what facts made you determine whether an amicus attorney was a good choice? Whether it was the right call or the wrong call, what would you look at?
Cindy Aguirre: Depending on what the complaint is, from the parent who is seeking it, even if it's a call that I would make where nobody's asking for an amicus attorney, I might go ahead and have someone come in and help me decipher the situation. For example, you have two great parents, or the difference between them is not huge, and you have a child who is expressing an interest, or one of the parents is saying, "This is what I think my child is going to say." Well, is that really the case? There's the sense of comfort, of making sure that you're making the right decision. It's a big deal. It's a lot of power in one person's hands to be able to make the right decision. So I think that is a concern.
I think your question is probably because maybe not every case is designed for an amicus attorney. Sometimes you have to look at it from the perspective of, am I going to have the parties go through this huge expense? It depends on the age of the child. If you have a child that is very little and can't really express anything, does that impact the decision? I think all of those things are considered.
Alex Hunt: If you take off your judge hat and put on your attorney and advocate hat, what cases would you want to see an amicus attorney appointed? Not from a judge's perspective, but from an attorney's perspective, where would you say, "I think I need an amicus because it's going to help our case"?
Cindy Aguirre: Definitely when you have a kid that's expressing a desire. Is the desire legitimate? Is it for the right reasons? Sometimes you may have a stubborn parent on the other side who is seeking custody for the wrong reasons. In order to give a little bit more strength to your case as a parent, you can go in there and not only corroborate that my client is the one who should be in the primary position, but also help explain to the other side that they're not going to get custody in this case, and then maybe we can get the case settled. Remember, that's the other role, and I think that's where judges also say, "I think I'm going to put this extra person in there," because the other role of the amicus attorney is to help the parties settle the case.
Alex Hunt: Definitely. That's one role of an amicus attorney. The other, as we talked about, is that you're the court's eyes and ears. Especially in mediations, I explain to folks that if you take this to trial, or say even a temporary orders hearing, because a lot of times the courts are so overburdened with cases, they'll say you get 45 minutes, especially in Harris County. The client will say, "Well, I've got a lot of information to present," and they provide us with a lot of evidence, and I always appreciate that. But the judge is going to see this much of your life. Sometimes having an amicus attorney allows the court to have somebody they trust go and be the court's eyes and ears, then report back and present what they believe is in the child's best interest. That can be very helpful for a judge and very helpful for a litigant too, if you're worried that the court is only going to see a small snippet of what's really going on. What are some of the biggest mistakes you've seen parents make when an amicus attorney is appointed on a case?
Cindy Aguirre: I don't know that it's really mistakes. I think it's hard for them. They don't really understand the role. I try to let them know, "Hey, I'm not the one making any kind of decision. I just need you to be you." I think it's trying to present as someone that they're not, because they feel like they're being looked at as if they were presenting testimony in a case. What works much better is when they're just real. You're not presenting a case to the amicus attorney. The amicus attorney is getting involved in your day-to-day life, as a real person, not as a witness testifying before a judge or jury. I don't necessarily think it's a mistake. I think the anxiety of the case drives that. So I try to say, "Hey, we're just talking. I need you to give me a list of what your concerns are. Tell me if there are other people you want me to talk to. But rest assured that I'm going to help you." I think that's important to people. I'm going to help you understand the process along the way, but I'm not the one making the decision. I just need you to be real, not present testimony.
Alex Hunt: I think that's excellent advice, just to be real, because amicus attorneys, especially somebody like yourself with a lot of experience, you've probably got a pretty well-tuned phony meter, and you can see when somebody is giving you a bunch of baloney versus giving you the real story. You can see how you interact with your child and if it's real, and then the amicus attorney is going to go and speak with the child alone, too, so the truth generally comes out. It's better to just be real, to show all the blemishes and warts on your case and be upfront about it rather than trying to hide it all behind a curtain of sunshine.
Cindy Aguirre: Right. And a list of things, or "my attorney told me to tell you." That kind of stuff is important, but I try to let them know, "That's great, I need the information, because that's important. But also tell me why this is important to you." I think that makes a difference, to understand what is driving that tug and pull with a child.
Alex Hunt: That's great advice. Let's shift gears a bit to your perspective as a judge on the bench, to see what you actually look for in custody cases. You've presided over, I imagine, hundreds of custody disputes over your time on the bench. What do parents obsess over that may barely register for a judge? And what do they overlook that is really important to a judge?
Cindy Aguirre: I think that takes me back to what the expectation may be for the litigants as to what the court can actually resolve. It's the minutiae. When you're there as a judge making a decision about rights and duties, for example, it's not about being able to take the child to the doctor when the child is sick. It's so much bigger than that, because it's not as microscopic as people think it is. I would look for who is going to understand that there are two homes now for the child. It's not "my home is the only home." When you're presenting testimony and your client says, "Well, my son came home, and my daughter..." you can't express that it's a child that is of both of us. It's not a possession. I think those small things, when the clients are presenting testimony and talking about what's important, are really about understanding that there's no ifs, ands, or buts about it. Unless it's a dire situation where you have somebody under supervised access, the child is still going to go back and forth between the two homes. People don't understand that they should be encouraged to love the other parent, and encouraged to understand that people's lives move on. Not because you have to have an existentialist conversation with the child, but maybe an ex-spouse has remarried. Is a parent volatile toward the new spouse? Those are things a child can't control. I think generally people underestimate what judges are thinking in that regard. Judges are looking at the dynamic. Who is going to be the one that says, "It's okay if he left the shirt at your house, we'll get it the next go-round"?
Alex Hunt: So it sounds like the parents who are going to be, you said the word volatile toward the other side, parents who are going to show, even on the little things, that they're going to be a more willing co-parent. They're going to be more easygoing. They're going to try to encourage the other parent to have a relationship with the child. Those are things you would pick up on.
Cindy Aguirre: Right. And I think people confuse that, as if the expectation is that you have to have a good personal relationship with the other parent. Technically, your child doesn't even have to know that you don't communicate very well, or that a horrible episode happened, like an affair or something really egregious toward the family. Kids don't have to be explained those things, and they are going to genuinely love both parents. When you present in a case where you're so rough, and you don't understand that your personal dispute is not anything your child can control, your child is in the middle of that situation, having to look to both of you, or not being able to tell a parent "I love you." Courts are looking to see who is going to understand that it's difficult, and who is encouraging in those situations. It doesn't mean you give it all away, but you can work with the other parent, you understand that things happen, and that the child shouldn't be the pawn in all of this.
Alex Hunt: No, certainly. My experience from talking with kids who have been placed in that situation, where one parent has really kind of stepped over the line and told them about another parent's affair or bad behavior, is that those kids, maybe not in that moment, but maybe when they get a little bit older and look back on it, really resent being put in that situation. It destroys their innocence and pits them against the other parent, and they have no role in that relationship. It can backfire. It might not backfire in that moment. You might think you're getting some sort of advantage over the other parent, you might be actively alienating, but later on that child will remember that you placed them in that situation and can resent that for some time to come. So there are just so many reasons not to put your kids in the middle of disputes between parents.
Cindy Aguirre: Right. And I think that's a lot more transparent. Judges pick up on those things. I think people focus on "he lied" or "she had an affair." Yes, those are important things, but when it comes to the relationship with the child, I don't think judges are focusing on what drove you to the courthouse or the breakup of the family. They're trying to figure out where kids are going to have emotional support, where they're going to have consistency and stability that is long term, and that is not going to be exclusive of this other half of their life.
Alex Hunt: Take us inside the courtroom. When you're sitting on the bench and you have a party before you, whether they're on the stand or they just enter the courtroom, what can destroy their credibility in your eyes in the first five minutes? And what could help really build them up in a short amount of time? Is there anything you looked at that would immediately build an impression?
Cindy Aguirre: I think that when you have bad facts, pretending the bad facts aren't there or minimizing the impact of the bad facts is never a good idea. I would much prefer that you just tell me what they are. We can deal with what the bad facts are. Falling on your sword and just acknowledging a bad judgment call is much more real, because all of us make bad judgment calls at some point in our lives. When somebody is on the stand pretending the bad judgment call wasn't a bad call, or justifying it for some reason, that's where you lose credibility. You lose credibility as somebody who is not going to make the same mistake again, or who is going to provide that type of stability. For me, that was very important: just tell me what it is, and we can deal with what it is. Dancing around it or pretending it's not an issue is a bigger problem.
Alex Hunt: Would you prefer that people bring that up in direct examination and explain it themselves, rather than you getting an impression of one of the parties and then they get cross-examined and all these bad facts come out? Would you rather they just tell you up front?
Cindy Aguirre: Yeah. It's just better overall. It's disappointing to a certain extent when you go, "Okay, so you were trying to convince me of this, but you failed to tell me why that was the case, or how it came to be, and there's this whole other part of it." Then you're like, "Did you try to fool me?" I think that's important for attorneys to know in general, because that's what judges are looking for.
Alex Hunt: That makes a lot of sense. The hardest cases, where there's no abuse, no neglect, no drug abuse, no terrible facts, I imagine those are the hardest cases for a judge to determine custody. How does a judge even begin to decide custody in a case like that?
Cindy Aguirre: Gosh. You have to go back to the code. You can't bring yourself into the emotion of the situation. I think that's where it's more important to look historically at what has gone on. For those of us who have a sixth sense about families and situations of this sort, that's where I think an amicus attorney having actual input, one way or another, is important. It doesn't make it any easier, but when you're there in that judicial capacity, you understand that you are there to help people get past this and get some closure. When you bring all of that together, you just know.
Alex Hunt: That's great. Not everybody can afford to have an attorney represent them in court. What's one thing you wish, when you were on the bench, that every self-represented litigant knew when they stepped into your courtroom in order to be successful?
Cindy Aguirre: I'll say it's hard representing yourself, and I certainly don't recommend it. It's not just because I'm an attorney. I'm sure you've seen it too. It's a complicated system.
Alex Hunt: It is.
Cindy Aguirre: It's hard to have an expectation of what they should know. In family court, you see people at their lowest. They come in having to admit, or try to deny, or try to forget, or try to explain away huge mistakes sometimes. I think the judges are there to help litigants, to just listen for a second, and to explain to them that there are rules. When a pro se litigant says, "I understand what you're asking, but there are rules that we have to follow," you have to be empathetic and show that you're not there to kick them at their lowest point. It's hard for me to express what they should know walking in. I think people who come into a family courtroom want to be heard, and that has to be navigated in a way that's judicially effective, because of all the rules that have to be followed. I'm no longer there, but when you are there, you have to listen. Your job is to help people through a very difficult time in their life. Nobody goes in there jumping up and down, rarely, maybe adoptions. But even in the most difficult situations, once litigants feel that they are heard, or that things are explained to them, things tend to go a little bit smoother. At least they did for me.
Alex Hunt: That's excellent guidance. A custody case has a number of other individuals, other than an amicus attorney, that might be helpful to the parties and to the court: a child custody evaluator, a parenting coordinator, a parenting facilitator. Some listeners might be unfamiliar with what they are and what they do. When does a judge reach for a child custody evaluator versus an amicus attorney being appointed? Maybe the best place to start is to explain what a child custody evaluator does, and then say why you would appoint an evaluator as opposed to an amicus attorney.
Cindy Aguirre: The biggest difference, of course, is that you have a forensic psychologist component. There's an assessment there that an amicus attorney is not equipped to make. I think that is helpful in situations where you have parents who are so adamant about their positions. They're both looking at things from a different eye, but are still in a very high conflict situation. For folks who aren't familiar, an amicus attorney is an attorney. There's no requirement that you have any type of forensic or therapeutic background. I certainly am not a therapist or psychologist. A child custody evaluator has specific requirements: they need to have a background in those sciences. They can go and get an entirely different in-depth look at each of the parties and their backgrounds and what is driving where they are today, what they're seeking today, and the decisions they make with regard to a child. There's testing that is done and evaluated by the forensic psychologist.
In these high conflict cases where you have parents who are very determined to take the case to trial, which they're entitled to, the other component for judges is the amount of time these evaluations take and the amount of money they cost. It's not cheap, and sometimes it can take two years to get a full report. That's the other difference, especially if you have somebody who's very thorough. They're very valuable, but they take a long time. That has to be factored into the decision of whether one is warranted.
The other stark difference is that sometimes you need a report. Sometimes you need a parent to look at an assessment and read about themselves and the other parent to get a better understanding of what's really going on and how their child is being affected. An amicus attorney doesn't produce a report. That's a huge difference that has to be factored in when you're deciding on having one or the other, or both. Sometimes it's warranted to have both, because the amicus attorney can give you a more in-depth look at many collateral witnesses and different aspects of life or different situations that have gone on throughout the case, whereas the report from an evaluator is much more psychological and scientifically backed, based on their background and expertise.
Alex Hunt: And unlike an amicus attorney, who is an attorney participating in the case as an attorney, who can call witnesses and ask questions during the trial, a child custody evaluator is a witness, or can be, and usually is if you've paid all that money. A witness in the case who will produce that product, give an ultimate opinion on what should happen with custody, and then be able to explain it in court. So, two very different roles. Shifting gears to parenting facilitators and coordinators. These are two roles that I would imagine a lot of even family law attorneys don't utilize very much and don't really know what they are. Did you have a lot of opportunity when you were on the bench to appoint parenting facilitators and coordinators?
Cindy Aguirre: I did. I didn't use those roles as frequently as I see them used now.
Alex Hunt: So you've seen an uptick?
Cindy Aguirre: I have more recently. But I also think there's a huge misunderstanding as to what facilitators and coordinators are there to do. I think a lot of litigants think that the facilitators or coordinators become the new triers of fact, and that's not what they're there for. The other difficulty is that as facilitators and coordinators, when you set appointments or make recommendations, they are recommendations that are meant to be followed, but you can't make them be followed. That's the difficulty, at least for me, in those roles. I think people expect that they're going to continue to have somebody chime in and say you're right, you're wrong, and that's not the role of the facilitator or the coordinator. Depending on what the specific requests are, they might be the tiebreaker on a specific situation. They're there to explain, "No, your order says this, so this is what that means, and this is what should be done in regard to this particular issue." But it's also more so the co-parenting aspect of it: come together so that we can find some common ground and put some rules in place that help you navigate these issues. They can be regular meetings or on an as-needed basis. But where there's a disconnect is that the parties may think those roles are designed to basically take the place of a judge who is going to come in with a gavel and say, "You're in contempt." That needs to be more clearly expressed to the litigants.
Alex Hunt: I've run into that a lot. They're parenting facilitators. They're supposed to be facilitating the co-parenting relationship, and they can do some level of coordination. What situations, when you were on the bench, did you find yourself utilizing a parenting facilitator or parenting coordinator? Where does it make sense?
Cindy Aguirre: To me, it's when the lack of communication is such that both parents are doing good parenting, but they're doing parallel parenting, and that sometimes becomes more difficult for the child. They may say, "This is happening at my house but not at yours." In that regard, helping them understand, "Okay, if I have a little window into what's going on in the other house, then maybe some of our rules should be the same in both," to get that understanding and help the transition of the parents being able to work together again. To me, that's probably the most beneficial use of a facilitator or a coordinator.
Alex Hunt: As family law practitioners, we talk a lot about co-parenting, but you mentioned parallel parenting. Have you ever seen a situation where parallel parenting has worked or is warranted, and you say, "Maybe co-parenting isn't for y'all. Maybe you need to do parallel parenting"?
Cindy Aguirre: Yes, unfortunately so. I say unfortunately, but in one particular situation I said, "I think definitely parallel parenting is what needs to happen right now." The conflict between the parents was so high that no conversation could take place without having to address some historical issue that led them to the splitting of the family. When the parents, as adults, can't get past that, time is the only thing that will help. I do think parallel parenting is helpful in that regard, because it draws lines that need to be respected until enough time has passed, until enough healing has passed, where the parents can begin to work together again. I don't think it's a forever thing, because I also think life tends to happen, and that's inevitable. But you have to recognize, as litigants and amicus attorneys and judges, that sometimes it's warranted, because the level of conflict between the parents is so high that unless you put some limits and rules in place and they learn first to coexist and leave the past behind, they won't be able to co-parent.
Alex Hunt: That makes a lot of sense. If somebody is in a high conflict case right now, how would they know whether it's the right call to ask for an amicus attorney or a child custody evaluator or a parenting facilitator? And where might that be a strategic mistake for them?
Cindy Aguirre: I think the assessment has to come from first identifying what the issues really are, and looking at where you are in the lifeline of a case. Are we at the beginning of the case? The end? In the middle? Are we going to a judge or a jury? What are the issues that are really keeping us from being able to come to an agreement that we think is best for our children? Have we attended mediation and gotten input from yet another attorney involved in the field who can say, "This is an issue that maybe would get resolved"? If you're concerned about safety and well-being, why not have somebody go out there? The fastest, cheapest way is with an amicus attorney. If there's a mental health component to a case, then maybe there should be an assessment from an evaluator who can forensically and psychologically interview the parties and do testing that is assessed. But I think it depends on the lifeline of the case as well.
Alex Hunt: I imagine, especially when you have a child custody evaluator, somebody with that expertise, and there is a mental health issue, you really valued that opinion since you don't have that same background. When these individuals, an amicus attorney or an evaluator, make a recommendation, how much weight does it carry when you're on the bench?
Cindy Aguirre: For me, I would evaluate the evidence and look at it as, "If I'm going to make the decision based on the evidence I'm receiving, this is kind of my gut feeling." Then the experts would help me, as the support for the decision that I'm making, that it's the right call. I would take a lot of notes, a lot of notes, and really look at the demeanor. I really took in that real aspect of the case that was being tried. I would listen to the testimony and evidence from these reports and experts, but I would first try to make a raw assessment: if I were to make a decision based on what I'm hearing, what I'm looking into with the parties, the arguments being made, and the facts as they're presented, does the psychological aspect support it? Or should I look into it from another perspective, because it doesn't support it? Why is that?
Alex Hunt: Were there ever circumstances when you were on the bench where an expert child custody evaluator or an amicus attorney made their recommendation clear and then you ultimately went in the other direction?
Cindy Aguirre: I can't say that I remember that happening. You made me think, and I can't say I remember ever coming across a situation like that. For me, it was probably more aligned.
Alex Hunt: And you're the one appointing the child custody evaluators, so you obviously trust the recommendations of those professionals. You're recommending folks whose work you've seen before, maybe even in private practice, so you take their word a little more seriously, because you do trust them, and that's why you appointed them to begin with.
Cindy Aguirre: Sure. And I think people have to realize that. Your judges aren't going to put people on cases that they just don't trust. Now, that doesn't mean they're not going to look at other aspects of the case, and sometimes it may be warranted. I don't remember that I ever had to do that. We're talking about custody cases, but there are other types of experts that people bring in. Now that I'm on this side, I will tell you that when you're considering evidence and taking all of that in, it has to make sense. There's a logical component to everything being presented. You have to hear it, look through everything that is being presented, and it all tends to fit. When you have an expert like that, for me, it was just a way of going, "Okay, I'm comfortable now making this decision."
Alex Hunt: That makes a lot of sense. My final question for you: you have this really unique experience as an amicus attorney, as an attorney in private practice, and as a former judge. What's the one thing you would want every parent coming into family court to know before they step inside?
Cindy Aguirre: Just one thing, or more than one thing? Even with my mediations, I start out with what their expectations are. I think understanding that the system is not equipped to put the life back together again. 100%. The system is not equipped to micromanage every phone call, every hour, every possible circumstance. Courts are there to solve the problem today with the facts as they are today. Specifically with children's issues, they are not final, forever orders. Should circumstances change, which most of the time they do, inevitably, do you have to go back? Unfortunately, yes. But courts are reactive, not proactive. I think people come in thinking, "I just don't know if there's going to be enough food there," or "I just don't know if she's going to take the child to the doctor." Those are things the court can't really operate on, and people don't understand that. It's a difficult thing, because it's a very logical rationale from the parent's perspective. It's not a crazy concern. It's a legitimate concern, but the court can't go in and micromanage and fix.
Alex Hunt: I think some of the most difficult conversations I need to have with my clients are when clients come to me because they want to seek justice. But justice is within a certain lens. It's within the lens of what's possible under the Texas Family Code and under the Texas court system. If you're seeking this idealistic sense of justice with a capital J, justice in the eyes of God, that's just not going to happen in the Texas family court system. And I imagine that was probably frustrating for you at times, that there would be things you would want to do that might be best for families, but under the law you can't do that, and you are bound to follow the law as a judge.
Cindy Aguirre: Right. Those are always very difficult conversations to have with clients, to kind of reshape the lens through which they're looking at their case, particularly in mediations, when they're deciding whether to reach a resolution or not. I get asked that a lot. Alex, I consider myself very, very lucky, because I really like what I do. I wholeheartedly feel that the roles I've had in my career are the reason I like them, because they allow me to help people get through very difficult times. I get asked a lot, "Gosh, you're not on the bench anymore." I was very grateful to Judge Perwin for having given me that opportunity. It was a wonderful opportunity, and I really enjoyed every aspect of it. But what is unique about what I do now is that it gives me the opportunity to sit down and look at people and explain to them why judges can't sit there and hold your hand and tell you, "I'm sorry this happened to you," or "This is the reason I'm making this decision." You're not going to get that explanation. Judges can't do that. Explaining the flaws of the system can't come from the bench when you're making those decisions. You can do that when you're sitting with somebody in a mediation or as an amicus attorney and say, "I understand what your concern is, but the courts can't fix that. So how do we come to a better resolution for your family so that we can move on from that?"
Alex Hunt: Well, your perspective now as a mediator is so important, because you've worn the judge hat, so you can tell litigants before they step into the courtroom and go to a final trial what they should expect, what the judge is looking for, and what a possible outcome of that process would look like. I think people really need to take it seriously when they consider that jump from a mediation and a possible mediated settlement agreement, where they are controlling their own destiny and reaching the outcome, versus going into a courtroom, which is a public setting. There's going to be mudslinging, and if you have kids, you're going to have to continue to co-parent with this person. Some of those things maybe could be forgiven, but they can't be forgotten. There are things that will be said that the other side is going to remember forever and that are going to color your relationship with the other side. The other thing about mediation is that some people need their quote-unquote day in court. They need to have a third party listening to their story and how they were wronged, and sometimes a mediation can fulfill that role, and somebody who will listen like you do is really important. You can give them that perspective and let them feel like they've had that day in court without going through the expense and the stress of a final trial. Not to mention the fact that it's family court. You never know what's going to happen. If you have a family lawyer who tells you with 100% certainty, "I know this is going to be the outcome of your case," that's just not true, because I can't tell my clients that even when I think it's a slam dunk. You don't know what's going to come out. So it's a very neat role that you have now, mediating cases and helping families that way.
Cindy Aguirre: Well, in mediations you also have the person there, and you can ask them why, logically, that makes sense. "Explain to me, to see if I can help you. Why do you think that's the way to resolve this? Why wouldn't you consider this other option?" I think people are appreciative of that. At the end of those very difficult thought processes, I think people are grateful. They say, "Thank you for the time you've spent with me."
Alex Hunt: Well, Judge, you've allowed us to take a lot of your time. I really appreciate that, and thank you for sharing your background and your expertise and your really unique perspective. It was a wonderful conversation. Where can folks find you online, or if they do need an amicus attorney in Fort Bend County or the Houston area, how can they find you?
Cindy Aguirre: I don't know how everybody's finding me in that regard, but they seem to find me. I'm usually in front of a computer, so I'm pretty easily found. Judge Perwin and I, when we left the bench, opened up our firm together. We have our firm in downtown Richmond, and we have a website, and people can log on and schedule mediations there. When we left the bench, I wasn't necessarily saying, "Hey, I'm out here doing amicus work again." I think I probably had one attorney call me up and say, "Hey, are you doing it?" and I said, "Okay, I'll do this for you." But lots of times people say, "No, we don't want her, because I'm very direct."
Alex Hunt: And sometimes that's why we do want you.
Cindy Aguirre: But no, I'm happy to help when I can, and I'm easily found. We have our website out, and my email is [email address unclear in the captions, please confirm] at Perwin Aguirre.
Cindy Aguirre: Also, hunt [name unclear in the captions, please confirm] down. He needs to get back to doing some amicus work.
Alex Hunt: Sounds good. Well, thank you again so much. And if you're looking for a family lawyer in the greater Houston area, you can find me at Hunt Law Firm, familylawyerkaty.com. You can also call us at [phone number unclear in the captions, please confirm]. Thank you so much again to former judge Cindy Aguirre for joining me. I'm Alex Hunt. We'll see you next time.